Friday, July 1, 2016

Careful What You Write in YA Books!!

Books are something that everyone enjoys reading, especially since there are a variety of genres to choose from. Would you like a book about animals? How about mysteries? Or a travel guide? Perhaps a photography book? These days however, the craze is all about YA. It must have started with the Twilight trilogy.

It's not surprising if you think about it. Twilight is a very successful franchise! There are four books and four movies I think? Or five books? Five movies? Eh, I'm not sure. The point is, this is a book based on the writer's dreams, that became hit enough to be turned into movies, and then those movies inspire an entire spoof movie. That's like a mini jack pot, considering the Harry Potter franchise must be THE jack pot!

Anyway, once Twilight came out, there's been a lot of books that have been roaming around most bibliophiles' orbit, all Young Adult novels with elements of the supernatural. I've decided to review one of these books, mainly because I have issues with the story that I feel should definitely be talked about.

6339664Romance was not part of Nora Grey's plan. She's never been particularly attracted to the boys at her school, no matter how hard her best friend, Vee, pushes them at her. Not until Patch comes along. With his easy smile and eyes that seem to see inside her, Patch draws Nora to him against her better judgment.
But after a series of terrifying encounters, Nora's not sure whom to trust. Patch seems to be everywhere she is and seems to know more about her than her closest friends. She can't decide whether she should fall into his arms or run and hide. And when she tries to seek some answers, she finds herself near a truth that is way more unsettling than anything Patch makes her feel.
For she is right in the middle of an ancient battle between the immortal and those that have fallen - and, when it comes to choosing sides, the wrong choice will cost Nora her life.

I'll just tell you about what disturbed me about this book. Basically, it involves Nora, the main character who is a bit of a nerd. And every nerd going to high school is supposed to have a bully. In Nora's case, it's Marcie, the classic rich girl who just loves bullying one particular person. Like I said before, wonky polygonal relationships are very difficult to execute- and this was not well written in my opinion. But we're not here to to talk about to character analysis and sketches. What I wanted to talk about was a recurrent conversation between Nora and Marcie, where they tossed around insulting slurs at each other before Nora finished things off with "anorexic pig".

(source: Fitzpatrick, Becca, 2009, Hush Hush, Simon and Schuster, London, p213)
Oh great, they’re swapping slurs. I really needed that.
So, Marcie goes with the classics “geek” and “freak”. There’s been a lot of references to Nora being a good...
This was my first time being exposed to the word anorexic. It was a word being describe a girl whose physique, when described, matched mine and for a full year, I thought anorexic meant skinny and the fact that anorexic was made to sound like it was a reason for being a bully really hurt me.

So imagine this really skinny seventeen year old girl, completely clueless about the word anorexic and the first time she comes across it, it's the main character using it as a derogatory term for a bully. For a full six months, there were countless moments when I'd be aware of myself and I'd hear myself reading out the words in my head-
pig! pig! anorexic pig!
Is that okay? No. That's not okay. It's great that Hush Hush affected me, but this was a very negative effect. If your book can do this to a seventeen year old, what will it do to someone younger? Someone fifteen, thirteen? Kids who are heading over to the YA section? We're not even talking about all the other things wrong with this book? Oh wait, we should.

Nora is a bully herself (she wishes she thought up of a crueler and more demeaning insult for Marcie- not that anorexic pig is all rainbows and flowers, right?) and is generally a character who is difficult to like. You'd think she'd have some redeeming qualities but to be honest, it's hard to see them when all you associate with this character is body shaming. Even Bella was better- she was polite and didn't needlessly sling mud around.

Patch is a stalker who says the creepiest things and is very very far from romantic- he's a psychopath and should be avoided at all costs. Like, yeah I get it, he's an angel and the plot is constricted and waterproof so it seems like what's happening is the only thing that can happen for him, but that doesn't change the fact that it's really creepy!

So yes, this book was, in my opinion, horrendous. I wouldn't recommend this book to anyone. I'd tell the writer to please consider rewriting this saga. I'd tell the publisher and editors to please hand in their resignations or at least take a few literature classes to see what proper novels should be like.

What kind of popular books do you find yourself disagreeing with? What issues do you find sensitive in young adult novels? Let me know in the comments below! Have a nice day!


  1. I agree, and I think you made some really excellent points! To me, that really sounds like it was trying to make Nora's bullying behavior "okay" because she was the protagonist. Someone can respectfully stand up for themselves without turning into a bully themselves.
    Plus, the problem with Patch is one I see a LOT in YA - making creepy stalkers come off as romantic. Like, no - if someone is stalking you and making you uncomfortable, you back away from them. I don't care what their intentions are - if you really want to establish a relationship with them, tell them you can't do it until they learn to respect your privacy, personal space, and limits. Communicate with them as to what you're uncomfortable with and distance yourself until you can determine if they've changed their behavior. Going along with it can lead to some really nasty things, including possessive relationships and rape.

    Ellie | On the Other Side of Reality

    1. Patch is, in my opinion, a much bigger overall problem. It's just that the whole anorexic thing really hit close to home for me, so for me as an individual, it ruined the book. But from a general perspective, Patch gives off wrong messages! Teenage girls should not be idolizing a fictional character with these traits. You're absolutely right, it only paves the way to bigger, worse things.

  2. Ah, Twilight, the series I love to hate. Four books, five movies. Golden rule of YA books-turned-to-movies: add one more for extra cash. But I guess they're better than these books. They were big back when I tried book blogging but I heard so much bad stuff about it that I didn't even bother picking it up. Now that I've seen the way the protagonist thinks about bullying and the use of the word 'anorexic' I'll make sure to stay far away from the book. I don't understand how a publisher thought this was a good idea. It's like they just publish every pile of garbage that fits the stereotype that followed the Twilight hype.

    x Envy
    Lost in Translation

    1. Twilight wasn't that bad in my opinion! I mean, sure it was really cheesy and everything, and yes there were times when some of the characters were weird, but at least no one was TRYING to make other people uncomfortable, whether by forcing themselves on other characters or bullying them! Whatever character problems there were in Twilight, remained limited to their characters, not to social issues. And I think that if you're going to discuss social issues in books, it should be done in a mature fashion. Which this author has done a terrible job at.

  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

  4. i didnt read a book for a while XD
    the last book that i read was a novel called "The Red Riding Hood"
    and it was good :D

    thanks for the recommend :D

    Shiro Usagi
    The Chronicle of Otaku

    1. To be honest, I don't recommend this book at all xD Stay away from it!


Feel free to comment and leave a link.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...